Disability: the case study

26th November 2014

News, Student news, Alumni news

Students, Oxford law faculty members and senior members of the judiciary gathered for the final of the inaugural Herbert Smith Freehills Oxford Disability Mooting Championship at Keble College on Saturday. Organised by graduate students from Wadham College and the Oxford Faculty of Law, the mock court case discussed the award of damages in a compensation case involving an individual who became disabled as a result of being hit by a motor vehicle.  

  • Finalists and judges in disability moot

    Grand finanlists with the judges (left to right): Ms Helen Mountfield QC, Matrix Chambers, Mr Ian Gatt QC, Herbert Smith Freehills’ Head of the Advocacy Unit (Just behind), Mr Conor Kennedy and Mr Stuart Sanders (Championship winners, and  both of Trinity College) and Professor Timothy Endicott, Dean of the Oxford Law Faculty.  (Photos by Alice Wang, Rhodes Scholar).

  • The judging panel assesses the evidence.

The Herbert Smith Freehills Oxford Disability Mooting Championship was organised to promote the intellectual study of disability and its intersection with domestic and international law. The Grand Final was judged by Professor Timothy Endicott, Dean of the Oxford Law Faculty, Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers KG PC, former President of the United Kingdom Supreme Court, Mr Ian Gatt QC, Herbert Smith Freehills’ Head of the Advocacy Unit, and Ms Helen Mountfield QC, Matrix Chambers.

After a fierce final round, against Mr Daniel Goldblatt (St Edmund Hall) and Ms Fiona O’Malley (Merton) the Grand Final was won by Mr Conor Kennedy and Mr Stuart Sanders both of Trinity College. Conor Kennedy, said: “Having not expected to progress past the group stages, it was an unexpected and quite intimidating honour to moot in front of the esteemed panel. The extremely interesting and finely balanced moot problem made it a thought provoking and fantastic experience.” Stuart Saunders continued: “We particularly enjoyed the stimulating panel discussion which followed the moot and were also very pleased to be able to be part of the wider disability awareness aspect of the event.”

The Grand Final was followed by a 'Conversazione' discussion moderated by Ken Macdonald QC, Warden of Wadham College and former Director of Public Prosecutions, on the theme: Building on the Paralympic Legacy: Social Attitudes, Equality Law and Participation in Public Life. The distinguished group of panellists included celebrated artist Ms Alison Lapper MBE, Mr Stephen Frost, the former Head of Diversity and Inclusion for the London Organising Committee of the Olympic and Paralympic Games, author and journalist Ms Katharine Quarmby and Mr John Lish, Expert by Experience for the Barker Commission.

Lord Macdonald commented: "This was an outstanding event and I hope it will become an established part of the Oxford legal calendar. There is so much to be done to raise awareness of disability issues in Oxford and around the country and the Disability Mooting Championship is a brilliant and thought provoking contribution to this much needed work."
 
Mr Dan Hudson, partner sponsor of Herbert Smith Freehills’ Ability Network commented: "Since launching our network in April, we have sought to raise awareness of disability issues inside and outside the workplace, challenge perceptions and encourage sharing of information and dialogue. Our support of the Disability Mooting Championship and partnership with the Oxford Faculty of Law on this project is a real highlight of our first year."

  • Conversazione panel

    Conversazione with (left to right) Daniel Hudson, Partner, dispute resolution; Mr John Lish, Expert by Experience for the Barker Commission; Mr Stephen Frost, the former Head of Diversity and Inclusion for the London Organising Committee of the Olympic and Paralympic Games; Ken Macdonald QC, Warden of Wadham College and former Director of Public Prosecutions; author and journalist Ms Katharine Quarmby; celebrated artist Ms Alison Lapper MBE.

  • Wadham student and event organiser Marie Tidball thanks the panel.

    Wadham student and event organiser Marie Tidball (2011 Criminology) thanks the panel.